New York Mets vs New York Yankees Prediction

Recent Form

Oldest on the left, most recent on the right — hover any result for the opponent and score.

Team Stats · 2026 Season

How The Model Sees It

The engine makes New York Yankees a 59.8% pick to win — a modest edge, real but the kind that loses often enough to sting. Baseball punishes certainty: the best team in the league still loses roughly four nights in ten. It is filed as lean, the third tier — a directional lean rather than a confident call.

Mets come in 7-3 over their last 10, scoring 6.90 and conceding 5.80 runs a game. Yankees are 7-3 in their last 10 at 5.10 scored and 3.50 allowed, on 4 straight wins. Neither side arrives with momentum the other lacks.

On the mound it is Zac Thornton for Mets against Gerrit Cole for Yankees — the largest single input on this page. One start moves a baseball projection further than a full lineup change would, which is why the engine waits for both probables before scoring a game.

Season run differential reads -32 for Mets and +123 for Yankees. Per game that is 4.34 scored against 4.56 allowed, versus 4.56 and 3.73. Yankees are clearly the better side on the season — and differential is a more honest measure than record, because it survives the luck in one-run games.

Yankees are 41-32 at home, Mets 35-39 on the road. Home advantage in baseball is real but small — historically worth something near 54%, not the lopsided edge it carries elsewhere — so the splits inform this projection without dominating it. The ballpark matters more than the venue: run environment varies more between parks than between lineups.

The projected total is 8.9 runs — a middling run environment. Through the first five innings, before the bullpens take over, it favours Yankees at 49% — under half because the first five is a three-way market: five innings can finish level, and that outcome takes a share of the book. Against the de-vigged market the model rates Yankees 33.9 points higher than the books. That disagreement is the interesting part — the market is sharp, so a departure usually traces to one specific input rather than noise.

This pick is published before first pitch and will be graded on this page once the game is final, whether it lands or misses.

8th Day Engine · mlb-sim-1.1